Do guaranteed credit cards exist?

credit card and pen©iStock.com/GerbertAndrey

AFTER a recession induced break 'guaranteed' credit cards are once again beginning to slip through UK letterboxes.

The siren call of pre-approval is likely to draw in more than a few consumers but do guaranteed credit cards actually exist?

Short answer

No.

Long Answer

Pre-approved credit card offers aren't actually offering guaranteed credit cards: 'guaranteed' implies that you're 100% certain to be accepted.

Yet no credit card actually offers guaranteed approval, all providers will expect you to undertake a credit check before you'll be considered, which means that your application could be declined.

'Pre-approval' itself is a more or less meaningless marketing term, it's simply an invitation to make an application.

However, declined applications look bad on credit scores but demonstrating a commitment to good borrowing practices is impossible without actually having a form of borrowing to use well.

No wonder, then, that people are on the look out for guaranteed credit cards and are so often disappointed when they turn out not to be guaranteed after all.

Disappointment

According to March 2011 research from CallCredit, 78% would be less than impressed after being turned down for a credit offer they received in the post.

In fact, 39% said they wouldn't deal with the credit card or loan provider again at all after being promised, and subsequently declined, borrowing.

A further 9% said they'd lose all trust in the brand that had offered them credit and 39% said it would give them a negative impression of the brand.

Like 'proactive' credit card marketing, which we cover here, advertising to existing cardholders, guaranteed card approval turns out to be a double-edged sword for companies as well as consumers.

The alternatives

'Poor credit' deals

Of course, some plastic that likes to pose as a sure thing does actually have a high chance of acceptance.

Yet CallCredit's research found that it wasn't always those deals which were being marketed through the post.

1 in 11 adults they surveyed said that they'd received an offer for credit that they thought was inappropriate as a result of their poor credit history.

The proportion was highest among 35-44 year olds: 15%.

An even higher proportion - 56% of people - didn't think that the credit card or loan offers they'd received were relevant to their financial situation more generally.

The researchers underlined the importance of research into application criteria and suitability before application, then.

While in no way being guaranteed credit cards, well researched credit cards can offer a higher chance of acceptance even for those that have a really serious problem such as bankruptcy (more on credit cards and bankruptcy here).

In particular, there are cards available to those with less than perfect credit scores and as such could be considered as easier to get accepted for. These cards are often known as bad credit rating credit cards (see comparison table).

Bad credit rating credit cards generally have high interest rates and no reward schemes or introductory offers. They're intended only for very short-term borrowing (within the 'up to 56 day' interest free period) and repairing a damaged credit score.

There are currently four major providers who offer sub-prime credit cards: Barclaycard, Capital One, Vanquis and aqua.

These are by no means guaranteed credit cards however. Applicants are still liable to be - and often, are - declined.

However, there is a third way: prepaid cards.

Prepaid Cards

Ok, so these aren't quite credit cards but, as our prepaid card article shows, they are probably the closest you can actually get to a guaranteed credit card.

Since prepaid cards aren't a form of borrowing they don't require applicants to undertake a credit check when they apply so - unlike 'guaranteed' credit cards - applications are actually generally guaranteed to be accepted.

Having said that, however, most mainstream prepaid cards will require some form of identification for the applicant to open the account and more advanced prepaid products - such as the CashPlus creditbuilder card - may require several forms of ID.

Comments

1
1 November 2014
Conrad Williams

The point of a loan or a credit card is to have available funds to pay off over a period of time. A pre paid credit card means you have to put an amount of money on that card. Whats the point? Is this just another way of banks or finance companies extorting money from consumers? I was turned down for a credit card due to, from what I was advised by
Experian, being out of the country with no registered address in the UK for nearly 2 years. I had recently been able to open a bank account for my wages, however due to having been accepted for three accounts, I was turned down due to my then low credit score. I think as explained in this thread, due to companies offering me credit then doing a credit
check and then turning me down through their own score acceptance, has put a glitch on my credit score. Therefore, it is down to me not to apply for any further credit for another year or so. Please explain then how a pre paid card is of benefit, when the company who issues them charges you a monthly fee?

Please read our full disclaimer for important information that relates to the service we provide and your use of this site.

We aim to provide free reviews and comparisons of consumer products and to keep our editorial content as objective as possible. To keep the site free, we are paid by some providers when new customers take products after they've clicked on our links. We don't allow our editorial content to be affected by those links, however we may not include all of the products available in the market. Finally, we do not submit or process any applications for any products or services and we cannot guarantee that any product or service listed on this website will be available to you. Credit providers make the final decision on whether an application for credit will be accepted.

If you would like to get in touch with us you can contact us here.