Is TalkTalk broadband any good?
AT THE time of this update, TalkTalk have just become the first of the big ISPs to switch to simpler, all-inclusive pricing.
They've used the change, as called for by the Advertising Standards Agency, as an opportunity to refresh their packages and brand image.
As well as looking to re-establish themselves as the UK's budget broadband and fibre kings, TalkTalk will be hoping it helps draw a final line under the concerns about their security, and their customer service - but is it going to be enough?
In this full review we'll look at their current prices, TV and other services, and take a hard look at their reputation for security and customer service.
As with most broadband providers, TalkTalk offer bounties for new customers. Currently they're offering:
As we may have mentioned already, TalkTalk broadband is cheap. But how cheap?
Because TalkTalk only offer unlimited broadband, it makes their basic broadband-only packages very simple. The choice is between standard or fibre varieties.
Here's how that breaks down:
As mentioned above, TalkTalk are the first of the big ISPs to adopt fully inclusive pricing for their broadband - so the prices listed above include everything but the cost of any extra calls customers make (more below).
TalkTalk's wireless routers are now completely free - as well as being included with all packages, there's no longer a charge for delivery.
Customers will also need to factor in a standard setup fee - usually £50, but occasionally offered for less or free of charge.
All contracts are a minimum 18 months long. This is worth bearing in mind when looking at free or reduced price introductory offers, which have previously tended to last six months to a year.
At the time of this update, however, TalkTalk are marking the introduction of their new pricing system with offers lasting the full 18 months on all their bundles.
All TalkTalk broadband packages must be taken with the provider's landline. Now they've moved to the all-in method of pricing, it's less obvious how much exactly that line rental is, but for those who still have to pay it, it's now £18.95 per month.
One casualty of the move to all-in pricing is their upfront line rental option.
Since December 2014, this has tended to reduce the cost of the line rental part of the bill by just under 10% over 12 months; a little later they brought in an 18-month version that offered a saving of 15%.
Existing customers who choose to stay with their old separately priced bundles can continue to pay line rental in one go, paying either £204.66 for the year (equivalent to a monthly cost of £17.06), or £289.93 for 18 months (just over £16 a month).
But Value Line Rental is not available for those moving across to the new all-in deals, or for completely new customers.
To add to this, standard line rental from TalkTalk doesn't include any inclusive calls, aside from those between TalkTalk customers (up to 180 minutes per month), so expect to add from £5 per month for calls to be included.
When they last refreshed their packages, in 2013, Simply Broadband cost just £2.50 a month. Before they switched to all-in pricing, it had risen to £7.50 a month.
Despite this, and the increasing cost of the phone line, TalkTalk continued to offer one of the least expensive broadband deals out there, because of their love of a good introductory offer.
In fact, despite their concerns about looking less competitive if they moved to all-in pricing before their competitors, their total monthly prices still come in lower than those of many of their rivals. See our guide for more detail.
The fibre packages have historically compared well to those from their biggest rivals on price, and continue to do so now - although comparisons aren't quite as simple as they were.
Here's TalkTalk's basic fibre deal, compared to the closest equivalents at BT, Plusnet, Sky, and Virgin Media.
As a result of BT upgrading their Infinity 1 fibre broadband to offer up to 52Mb, TalkTalk, Plusnet and Sky are at a slight disadvantage in that their entry level fibre appears to be slower than that offered by their biggest rival.
But the table above says it all - even against ISPs selling fibre that offers the same maximum speed, they're (just about) the cheapest per month. At the time of this update, they lose out to Plusnet only because of a very competitive introductory offer.
TalkTalk TV prices
TalkTalk offer the same Youview TV service that BT have, and that Plusnet offer their fibre customers.
Youview is essentially a Freeview service with up to 80 channels, plus seven day catch up and the ability to pause and rewind live TV.
TalkTalk offer two base packages: the newly renamed "TV" and "TV Plus".
The Youview box that comes with the basic TV bundle has no recording ability and can only pause or rewind live TV by up to 30 minutes; the channels offered are basically those we'd get with standard Freeview.
For that reason, there's a £25 fee for the set top box, but otherwise it costs no more than getting TalkTalk's broadband and phone - unless we choose to add one of TalkTalk's TV Boosts, listed below.
Upgrading to TV Plus costs an extra £12 a month. For that customers get an upgraded Youview+ box, with unlimited pause and rewind, up to 185 hours of TV recording and 30 more channels, including six Sky channels (not including Sky Atlantic), Fox, Gold and the History Channel.
All TalkTalk TV customers can further upgrade their service by adding monthly "boosts". They start from £5 a month for the Starter and Kids packs, up to £32 for six Sky Sports channels. Occasionally the boosts are offered cheaper - sometimes up to half price - so do check.
|TV Boost||Extra channels||Monthly cost|
|TV Starter|| Sky 1 and Sky 2,
Sky Living, Real Life, Sky Arts,
Sky Sports News HQ
|Kids||Disney, Disney Jnr, Disney XD,
Nickelodeon and Nick Jnr,
Baby TV, Boomerang, Cartoon Network
|Entertainment||30 extra channels (including TV Starter)||£12|
|Asian TV||Selection of Asian TV channels including Zee TV and Sony TV Asia||£10|
|Picturebox||On demand movies and TV box sets||£5|
(previously Sky Movies)
| 11 live Sky Cinema channels,
Sky Cinema On Demand
|Sky Sports||Sky Sports 1-5, Sky Sports F1||£32|
|Sky Sports + Sky Cinema||All available Sky Sports and Sky Cinema channels||£42|
|BT Sport||BT Sport 1 and 2, BT Sport Europe, BT Sport ESPN||£21.99|
|Boxnation||24/7 boxing channel||£12|
At the time of this update, BT Sport has just been made available on Youview from TalkTalk, at a cost of £21.99 a month, plus an activation fee of at least £15. Customers need to contact BT if they want to add the channel pack - there's more detail here.
On top of these boosts, TalkTalk offer Netflix through their Youview boxes, giving existing subscribers the chance to watch on a TV screen rather than a computer or mobile device.
People new to Netflix can sign up through the in-box app, with prices starting from £5.99 a month.
The fact that TalkTalk TV is customisable keeps basic prices low compared to competitors - and it has the bonus that customers only pay for what they want to watch. But the extra boosts can add up, so remember to factor them in when comparing between providers.
However, this clearly isn't a fair fight as Sky's basic deal offers far more channels than TalkTalk's, and Virgin offer much faster broadband.
As with the TV service, the phone service that comes with the broadband can also be customised with a couple of bolt-ons, and like the TV boosts they're offered on a month-by-month rolling basis, which adds some flexibility to the minimum 18-month contract.
Available boosts include:
- Anytime UK Calls Boost: Inclusive calls to UK landlines and mobiles at anytime (£7.50).
- International Saver Boost: Discounted calls to all international destinations (£2.50).
- International Extra Boost: 1,000 minutes to landlines in more than 50 international destinations; discounted calls to other countries (£5).
- International Max Boost: 1,000 minutes to landlines and mobiles in more than 50 international destinations; discounted calls to other countries (£10).
TalkTalk offer discounted mobile phone services to their residential customers, using the Vodafone network. Under the terms of that partnership they can only offer 2G and 3G services - but that seems to suit the roughly 400,000 customers who have at least one mobile with them.
However, in the face of a growing quad-play market, they're stepping up their mobile ambitions. At some point in the near future they'll be switching across to the O2 network, which will allow them to move into 4G.
Keen to start pushing quadplay services as soon as possible, in December 2014 they introduced a free sim, worth £5 a month, for what were then Plus TV customers, providing 100 minutes, 250 texts and 200MB of data.
In February 2016, they extended the free SIM deal to all their customers, new and existing, whatever package they have.
For a while they were known for offering what they called "Britain's lowest priced unlimited SIM", offering unlimited data, minutes and texts at an introductory price of £12 a month.
The deal appeared in April 2015 - but less obvious was the fact that the bargain price was for an introductory period only.
When the promotion ended in August 2015, the cost of the SIM rose to £24 a month - and by the start of 2016 there was no mention of the unlimited deal at all on TalkTalk's site.
That means there are once more only two networks offering unlimited data, texts and minutes: GiffGaff and Three, both of whom offer 4G as standard.
These days the most data TalkTalk offer as standard is 2.1GB with their Large SIM plan, with the option to add extra data boosts - as TalkTalk have said previously that even 3GB provides more than enough data for 95% of their customers.
TalkTalk had collected a formidable collection of wooden spoons for poor customer service in the past - and after a period where they showed some signs of improvement, they came in for serious criticism over how they handled the aftermath of the October 2015 data breach.
Customer service problems
Before 2015's problems, horror stories about the provider ran the gamut of broadband badness, from shoddy customer service to disrupted connections and billing disasters: it's fair to say TalkTalk customers had a pretty rough ride.
Partially, that's because of a huge billing mess up stemming all the way back to a 2009 takeover, which led to thousands being overcharged or charged despite having left. As they emerged from that crisis, the ISP's day-to-day service proved a problem.
Records were not always kept and reports of being endlessly passed from one TalkTalk department to another were common.
They seemed to hit their stride for a while towards the end of 2012, when data from Ofcom showed the number of complaints they were receiving about TalkTalk had dropped sharply.
At the end of 2014, while TalkTalk were still on the lower side of average for the industry, they were by no means the worst.
Where they continued to fall down, according to Ofcom, was with their customer service advisors. They performed below average on understanding customer issues and identifying problems (52% versus 64% average), and they score poorly regarding logging details.
See our broadband customer service guide for more detail on service.
But then came three data breaches in the space of 12 months; the first only came to the ISP's attention when they realised they'd been receiving more complaints about suspicious calls from people claiming to work for them.
Last October's attack was far less serious than first suspected, and the company said that their security was "head and shoulders" above that of their competitors.
The Information Commissioner's Office seem to have disagreed, as they announced the day we were writing this update that they were fining the ISP a record £400,000, saying that the attack "could have been prevented if TalkTalk had taken basic steps to protect customers' information".
Given the number of breaches in so short a period, it's not surprising that many customers lost faith in TalkTalk's ability to protect them and their data - and that's when the customer service issues began to crop up again.
Understandably shaken by the thought of large amounts of personal information having been accessed, those who said they wanted to leave were told they would still be charged penalty fees if they had time left on their contracts.
Others reported issues with the free upgrades they were offered by way of apology for any concerns caused.
However, claims that TalkTalk broadband is itself always of poor quality are far of the mark.
TalkTalk have their fair share of complaints and they don't always deal with them well, but millions of people have received decent enough broadband service and liked the ISP enough to stay put for years.
They are still the UK's fourth biggest broadband provider, and by a comfortable margin. Clearly they've been doing something right.
TalkTalk's technical side
Price and reputation are, perhaps, TalkTalk's biggest pro and con respectively but it's also well worth knowing about their broadband's speed and quality and about HomeSafe, their security and parental control software.
With fibre, TalkTalk are able to offer some of the UK's best speeds and often for a little less than BT or Plusnet, who are offering the same service.
Fibre is slowly catching on across the board, but it's still some way behind ADSL in terms of customer numbers.
ADSL: Figures from Ofcom's independent tests, released in March 2016, show that TalkTalk are offering the slowest standard broadband speeds:
|Overall average||Peak (8-10pm weekdays)|
|TalkTalk ADSL2+||7.5Mb to 9.3Mb||7.4Mb to 9.2Mb|
|8.9Mb to 11.1Mb||8.8Mb to 11.0Mb|
Even so, there's only a couple of Mb in it in terms of average speeds, and the speeds seem to remain consistent regardless of whether it's peak time or not.
To see what we mean, take a look at how they fared against their biggest "budget" competitor, Plusnet.
When we got the chance to compare them side by side, we found that while the Yorkshire ISP did offer higher speeds, they came at the cost of consistency.
Yes, TalkTalk were slower, but that speed was pretty much guaranteed whatever the time of day.
Fibre: Thanks to the rise in the number of people taking fibre broadband across the UK, Ofcom can now get accurate average speed results for almost all of the packages offered by the biggest fibre providers.
With the exception of Virgin Media, all of those fibre deals are resold versions of BT's Infinity broadband service (review here), with differences in the speeds achieved coming down to traffic and network management.
As TalkTalk still don't have enough up to 76Mb customers for Ofcom's purposes, we've used BT's Infinity 2 results - and included both TalkTalk's and BT's up to 38Mb results to show the kind of differences there can be between providers:
|Overall average||Peak (8-10pm weekdays)|
|TalkTalk up to 38Mb||31.7Mb to 35.1Mb||31.3Mb to 34.7Mb|
|Infinity up to 38Mb||34.3Mb to 35.5Mb||33.8Mb to 35.1Mb|
|Infinity up to 76Mb||57.4Mb to 61.1Mb||56.9Mb to 60.5Mb|
The boost from ADSL is significant, then, and worth the extra cost per month for high usage households.
For more on the differences between TalkTalk and other BT Infinity wholesale resellers like Plusnet, Sky and EE see our big fibre showdown guide.
But more important than speed, from TalkTalk's point of view at least, are services that underline - and could help to rebuild - their reputation as a user friendly ISP.
The most important of these is HomeSafe.
It's essentially a security system, much like the software we're used to getting from Norton, McAfee, Kaspersky and others, with the essential difference that the restrictions apply to every device using the wireless network: the iPad or laptop as well as the family PC.
It's a hit: according to Ofcom around 36% of TalkTalk customers use it - mostly, it seems, to prevent children from accessing inappropriate content, self-harm and violent sites.
See our parental control software guide here for more on HomeSafe and how it compares to the safety controls other ISPs are giving away free.
In addition to the free - and much imitated - Home Safe, TalkTalk now include the security "boost", SuperSafe, free for everyone for the first eight devices, and for £2 a month for more than eight.
A more traditional computer security system - in this case using F-Secure Internet Security - it protects PCs, Macs, tablets and mobiles from viruses and malware, and fake and inappropriate sites.
The bottom line
The bottom line is that TalkTalk still offer some of the cheapest and simplest ways to get online - and with the move to all-in pricing, they've earned even more points on both of those scores.
It's been good to see the improvements in their fibre and TV service and, after years of promises their customer service had been improving.
Although they came in for criticism for the way they handled some of the fallout from last year's cyber attacks, they did a pretty good job in keeping customers informed once the initial panic had died down, and offered them all free credit monitoring, to help them keep an eye on their accounts.
Whether that's enough to keep existing customers on board, and whether those issues will continue to put potential new customers off a generally consistent broadband service remains to be seen.